Return to Home Page

January 25, 2009

David Simon on how good television is like travel

Homicide, The Corner, The Wire, Generation Kill — these are travelogues of a kind, allowing Average Reader/Viewer to go where he otherwise would not. He loves being immersed in a new, confusing, and possibly dangerous world that he will never see. He likes not knowing every bit of vernacular or idiom. He likes being trusted to acquire information on his terms, to make connections, to take the journey with only his intelligence to guide him. Most smart people cannot watch most TV, because it has generally been a condescending medium, explaining everything immediately, offering no ambiguities, and using dialogue that simplifies and mitigates against the idiosyncratic ways in which people in different worlds actually communicate. It eventually requires that characters from different places talk the same way as the viewer. This, of course, sucks.

“There are two ways of traveling. One is with a tour guide, who takes you to the crap everyone sees. You take a snapshot and move on, experiencing nothing beyond a crude visual and the retention of a few facts. The other way to travel requires more time—hence the need for this kind of viewing to be a long-form series or miniseries, in this bad metaphor—but if you stay in one place, say, if you put up your bag and go down to the local pub or shebeen and you play the fool a bit and make some friends and open yourself up to a new place and new time and new people, soon you have a sense of another world entirely. We’re after this: Making television into that kind of travel, intellectually. Bringing those pieces of America that are obscured or ignored or otherwise segregated from the ordinary and effectively arguing their relevance and existence to ordinary Americans. Saying, in effect, This is part of the country you have made. This too is who we are and what we have built. Think again, motherfuckers.

“And the only difference between what we’re doing and a world traveler getting off the beaten path is that our viewers don’t really have to play the fool. They don’t even have to put their ass out of the sofa. They now have a sense of what is happening on a drug corner, or in a homicide unit, or inside a political campaign—and our content, if gently massaged to create drama, is nonetheless rooted in accurate reporting and experience.”

–TV writer-producer David Simon, interviewed in The Believer, August 2007

Posted by | Comments (1) 
Category: General, Travel Quote of the Day


One Response to “David Simon on how good television is like travel”

  1. jquaglia Says:

    “And the only difference between what we’re doing and a world traveler getting off the beaten path is that our viewers don’t really have to play the fool.”

    This seems like a pretty ego-centric thought process in his belief that what he is providing is comparable to travel. I would say that TV is completely the opposite of travel. Travel requires self-sufficiency, knowledge, open-mindedness, understanding, effort. TV seeks to put you there without any of the above. And you are subject to the interpretation of a place through the director, actors, and producers. Travel is about taking the effort of experiencing real people and real places ourselves rather than having someone tell us about them. Travelers are willing to make this effort because they recognize the incredible reward of experiencing things themselves, while TV viewers (who don’t travel) are expecting a cultural handout of sorts within their own relative comfort–impossible. Mr. Simon is crazy if he thinks he can offer an authentic cultural experience to someone from the comfort of their living room couch.

Leave a Reply

Main

Bio

Books

Stories

Essays

Video

Interviews

Events

Images

Writers

Marco

Guide

News

Paris

Vagabonding.net

Contact

Marco Polo Didnt Go There
Rolf's new book!


Vagabonding
   Vagabonding


RECENT COMMENTS

Facebook Skins: Thanks for the useful info…we are always looking for new blogs to...

Lisa Edmondson: Nice idea! My first baby, my little girl, studied every new object...

Sabina: Good for Sullivan McLeod! What would I do? I think almost nothing is...

sam fox: Im 14 yrs old and already plan on being a traveling journalist. I have already...

Rebecca Snavely: Wonderful post! And it reminds me so much of the movie...

Felipe Cerda: I’m Chilean and I live in the city of Concepción in the Bio-Bio...

GypsyGirl: Rodeo rules-Good for Sullivan! I rode bulls for two seasons- it’s...

GypsyGirl: This hits me as bitter-sweet…

Erick Recors: Initiation rules for me; my first group night out with a bunch of people...

Andy Fleming: Very interesting advice. We continue to try our best to travel and see...

SPONSORED BY :



CATEGORIES

TRAVEL LINKS

ARCHIVES

RECENT ENTRIES

Tokyo’s ancient eco past
Babies: a reason to travel
Resiliency in the face of tragedy
The initiation rites of travel
When you don’t have any experience, do it anyway
Men and women get different diseases while traveling
Volunteering at home
Travel and home are invariably intertwined
BootsnAll Announces New Platform for Travel Writers
Special March 2010 fares for multi-stop tickets on BootsnAll


Subscribe to this blog's feed
Counter