Return to Home Page

June 11, 2012

What do guidebooks say about your country?

Various travel guidebooks.

Various travel guidebooks. Photo: iandoh / Flickr

The Atlantic had an article titled Welcome to America, Please Be On Time: What Guide Books Tell Foreign Visitors to the U.S.  It was a little disorienting to read about your own country from the perspective of a foreigner.  When you live in a place where you grow up, it doesn’t occur to you to pick up the tourist literature.  For context, Lonely Planet is an Australian company (although now owned by the BBC), while Rough Guides are based in England.

What guidebooks say can be less than flattering.  An excerpt:

Lonely Planet urges caution when discussing immigration. “This is the issue that makes Americans edgy, especially when it gets politicized,” they write, subtly suggesting that some Americans might approach the issue differently than others. “Age has a lot to do with Americans’ multicultural tolerance.”

Ouch.  On the other hand, what’s enlightening about seeing things from an outsider’s perspective is that it points out differences you otherwise would have overlooked.  If you’re an American, you’d assume you wouldn’t sit at a stranger’s table and just strike up a conversation.  Yet this is normal in more crowded, communal countries where people share everything.

A particularly American norm that drives visitors crazy is tipping.  My friends from other countries have reacted with confusion, anger and frustration over how to handle this.  One Kiwi friend said flat-out, “I hate tipping.  It reduces all contact with service people to a financial transaction.  Why can’t America just pay them a living wage like civilized societies?”

I’d like to hear from our readers.  What countries are you from?  What have you read about your country in guidebooks?  What was true and what was false?  Please share your thoughts in the comments.

Posted by | Comments (2) 
Category: Notes from the collective travel mind, Travel Guidebooks


2 Responses to “What do guidebooks say about your country?”

  1. Adriano Says:

    “Nothing worth a visit”. This (and not much more) is what a few “researchers” have written about my province (showing btw that they actually haven’t researched so much…) This sentence sounds like the “mostly harmless” of a bigger, more famous guide…. ;-)

  2. Rolf Potts Says:

    Whenever I read a guidebook that covers my home state of Kansas I’m usually underwhelmed by how obvious and uninteresting all the recommendations are. To me, the essence of Kansas is so much more subtle and complicated. But then I realize that his probably applies to most anyplace — that any guidebook info is going to cover the major bases and miss the subtle stuff. This is why — anywhere/everywhere you go — it’s good to linger awhile and listen, to get off the beaten path.

Leave a Reply

Main

Bio

Books

Stories

Essays

Video

Interviews

Events

Writers

Marco

Paris

Vagabonding.net

Contact

Marco Polo Didnt Go There
Rolf's new book!


Vagabonding
   Vagabonding


RECENT COMMENTS

green coffee bean extract: After going over a number of the articles on your web site,...

reverse osmosis water filter: Simply desire to say your article is as astonishing. The...

RK: Hi Colleen, Hope you had a great hitch! I agree that anyone hitching should be...

2 Digital Nomads: Very touchy, thanks for sharing. I will tweet and post on FB too.

DEK: Very young children are wholly absorbed in their mother and oblivious to whether...

Andy Pac: I lived in China for a year and loved it. The people were friendly, kind,...

Turner: Under three years old? Then yes, absolutely. A waste of time and money.

bicyclegourmet: i wonder if some ancient asian sage offered advice about buying a live...

Jennifer Miller: Rubin: Agreed.

Sage: Java is a wonderful place and I loved the trains in Indonesia!

SPONSORED BY :



CATEGORIES

ARCHIVES

RECENT ENTRIES

Ellis Emmett: The nine most important things in life
Without travel, there would be no “us”
Charity school project in Bodhgaya, India
Vagabonding Field Report: Java, Indonesia
Vagabonding Field Report: Korea’s Demilitarized Zone (DMZ)
Is travel wasted on the very young?
Don’t fear failure
Pilgrims of yore had much in common with present-day tourists
Book review: Tearing up the Silk Road
3 Ways to invest in local economies


Subscribe to this blog's feed