Return to Home Page

November 19, 2012

Much of what we experience as travelers is mired in the imaginary

“What [tourists] bring to New Guinea, reinforced by the travel brochures, is clearly imaginary, that is, it is not based on any real assessment of the New Guineans, but is rather a projection from Western consciousness, with the reminder that the only way to explore the real is through one’s symbolic system. The tourists say that the indigenous people do not think about tomorrow, that they are “primitive,” that their lifeway is “so opposite to that of Europe,” all of which suggests the image of the happy savage and the natural man, close to nature, not yet burdened by the oppressions of European civilization. The New Guineans, in turn, in their sing-sings and performances put on for the tourists, do not display their real, but rather the New Guinean performance mirrors for the Europeans what the tourists desire. This mirroring is not a condition conducive to learning. According to Lacan, it does not work well in psychoanalysis and cannot lead to understanding of other cultures in tourism, because one never penetrates from the imaginary to the symbolic. The Europeans cannot progress to a more realistic appreciation of the New Guineans, because the Other reflected back to them is their own imaginary projection. They are trapped in a loop, in never-ending reflections from multiple mirrors.
–Edward M. Bruner, “Transformation of Self in Tourism,” Annals of Tourism Research, Vol. 18, No. 2 (1991)

Posted by | Comments (2) 
Category: Travel Quote of the Day


2 Responses to “Much of what we experience as travelers is mired in the imaginary”

  1. Roger Says:

    This quote is rather interesting to me because my first trip ever overseas was to Papua New Guinea, back in 1984. It was with a group of about 30 American college students, and for most of us this was our first trip abroad. I know we made some mistakes, but I believe our preparation before the trip set the right mindset, which was to be sensitive, respectful, and to learn to speak pidgin. The thing is, when you travel abroad, it helps to perhaps gradually integrate your way into the culture. We started out meeting with people who weren’t too different than ourselves and got grounded. Then, meet people who were more different. It wasn’t perfect, but I think it was a decent transition, and above all, I think the whole trip was positive and worthwhile. It definitely taught me a lot and drew me to more and more travel.

  2. DEK Says:

    Nothing sucks the romance and fun out of travel quite like the academic study of tourism.

Leave a Reply

Main

Bio

Books

Stories

Essays

Video

Interviews

Events

Writers

Marco

Paris

Vagabonding.net

Contact


Vagabonding Audio Book at Audible.com

Marco Polo Didnt Go There
Rolf's new book!


Vagabonding
   Vagabonding

RECENT COMMENTS

ussglenn.com: In addition, some agents also prepare an inventory of 17 models,...

Blondie aka Terri: I’m so glad that we stayed in touch (you know what I mean)! We have...

Peter Korchnak @ Where Is Your Toothbrush?: Agreed with Lynne, well said. The...

M.Jagger: Rod, Blimey….It was a blast partying with you at the local...

Ava Collopy: I’m currently working on a new book and website project to represent...

Caroline Macomber: I’m beginning to feel that it doesn’t end. But that I...

Stephen: Does it end, though? I’ve gone through several cycles of this over the...

Margie: I will never be a tour guide, but the prospective you have shown here will help...

Lynne Nieman: Well said! Although not a long term traveler like you, I have taken a few...

Dorje: Hi all. I was born in Kathmandu in ’71, my father ran the Rose Mushroom...

SPONSORED BY :



CATEGORIES

TRAVEL LINKS

ARCHIVES

RECENT ENTRIES

Maximilian I on the journey of life
Enlightening Self-inflicted Ruin Travel
Thank you, Victoria Falls.
Lost in the crowd when traveling?
Can words hurt as much as sticks and stones?
Vagabonding Field Report: The Penguins of Phillip Island
Long term travel with a family: You have to really want to do this
Alden Jones on going back to the places that obsess you
My top beaches around the world
Skepticism and salvation in Cyprus


Subscribe to this blog's feed
Follow @rolfpotts