Marshall McLuhan on how the modern traveler has become passive

“The photograph has reversed the purpose of travel, which until now had been to encounter the strange and unfamiliar. Descartes, in the early seventeenth century, had observed that traveling was almost like conversing with men of other centuries, a point of view quite unknown before his time. For those who cherish such quaint experience, it is necessary today to go back very many centuries by the art and archaeology route. Professor Boorstin seems unhappy that so many Americans travel so much and are changed by it so little. He feels that the entire travel experience has become “diluted, contrived, prefabricated.” He is not concerned to find out why the photograph has done this to us. But in the same way intelligent people in the past always deplored the way in which the book had become a substitute for inquiry, conversation, and reflection, and never troubled to reflect on the nature of the printed book. The book reader has always tended to be passive, because that is the best way to read. Today, the traveler has become passive. Given travelers checks, a passport, and a toothbrush, the world is your oyster. The macadam road, the railroad, and the steamship have taken the travail out of travel. People moved by the silliest whims now clutter the foreign places, because travel differs very little from going to a movie or turning the pages of a magazine. The “Go Now, Pay Later” formula of the travel agencies might as well read: “Go now, arrive later,” for it could be argued that such people never really leave their beaten paths of impercipience, nor do they ever arrive at any new place. They can have Shanghai or Berlin or Venice in a package tour that they need never open. In 1961, TWA began to provide new movies for its trans-Atlantic flights so that you could visit Portugal, California, or anywhere else, while en route to Holland; for example. Thus the world itself becomes a sort of museum of objects that have been encountered before in some other medium. It is well known that even museum curators often prefer colored pictures to the originals of various objects in their own cases. In the same way, the tourist who arrives at the Leaning Tower of Pisa, or the Grand Canyon of Arizona, can now merely check his reactions to something with which he has long been familiar, and take his own pictures of the same.”
–Marshall McLuhan, Understanding Media: The Extensions of Man (1964)

Posted by | Comments (3)  | April 8, 2013
Category: Travel Quote of the Day


3 Responses to “Marshall McLuhan on how the modern traveler has become passive”

  1. Roger Says:

    I see McLuhan’s point, but there is no reason in this erudite panacea to stop pursuing your travel dreams. One person’s routine experience may be another person’s eye opening epiphany. There is nothing passive or predictable about the travel bug, assuming you’ve got it. That said, I can see how the media distorts things. The term “travel bug” might even be purely concocted by the media. McLuhan wrote this in 1964, and I didn’t start traveling abroad until 1984, so a lot has happened since. His analysis is good inoculation, but still the young traveler is an innocent until lessons are learned.

  2. Jennifer Miller Says:

    Love this… thought provoking…. written before I was born, in the era in which my parents were backpacking their way around. More than anything I think it’s a reminder to pursue actively our travels through life… not just “travel” in the most obvious sense, but to resist the pull towards passivity in our dreams and life paths in general. So much of life continues to become “diluted, contrived & prefabricated” as it gets easier and easier to create a range of experiences, from travel to education. The things we value most are the things we are most active in pursuing and absorbing into ourselves… I’ll be thinking about this one for a while. Thanks Rolf!

  3. Roger Says:

    Well said, Jenn.