I don’t deal much with religion issues on this blog, but religion does intrigue me — and that’s why Elaine Pagels’s new book Beyond Belief, (which is about the Gnostic Gospel of Thomas) is on my reading list. It’ll be awhile before I get a chance to read it, but I did catch a great interview with Pagels at Edge.org. Much of it deals with a discussion about the circumstances under which the Christian gospels were written.
“Many Jews and many Christians have assumed that their holy scriptures were some kind of immutable truth that descended from heaven,” Pagels says. “That of course is the story of Sinai. And what this work shows, the work of historians of religion, is that in fact these kinds of texts are accretions that develop over time, they come out of arguments — you can show what those arguments are. You can show how opposite points of view are articulated in the traditions that these Christians think come straight from the mouth of Jesus himself, that in fact what’s put in the mouth of Jesus himself are words that come out of debates that occur 60 to 70 years after his death. Now that is interesting, because it makes it impossible to maintain a kind of literalist and simplistic view of revelation. That is really the basis of much Christian teaching, and in fact particularly much of American Christianity in particular.”
I’d be interested to hear feedback on the book from anyone who’s read Beyond Belief, where, apparently, Pagels expands on these kinds of topics.


October 19th, 2003 at 7:34 am
Hi Rolf,
I’ve been reading of Pagels and Nag Hammadi texts; it does not surprise me. I think people in general are against truths. Maybe truth is frightening. Maybe they feel it threatens their continuity as a person. Why is it so? Why they feel themselves threatened?
I think denial and repression are dangerous. Truth will be very shocking to people; – the more they deny, the greater the shock will be. A person should be able to take a little excitement, some change, something new and creative. But this goes against the ego. And when people have to choose between the truth and the ego, which will win? They harden their ego with steel armour. It is very sad.
Jukka
June 13th, 2006 at 3:15 pm
I was plesantly surprised reading the Gospel of Thomas, “the kingdom of God is within you and is ouside you”. Compare these wit the experience of Paul in 2Corinthians 12:2-3.
May 26th, 2007 at 8:21 pm
I¨m tryn to send a gift for Mme Elaine Pagels, would you please send it to me her pernosal mail? TKS