Return to Home Page

November 28, 2012

Authentic Asia: find it at the shopping mall

Recently I have been intrigued by something travel writer Tom Coote said on his website about the quest for authenticity in travel:
The concept of authenticity has largely been appropriated as yet another way to persuade gullible tourists to part with their hard earned cash. If you really want to get to know a country, you would be better off doing what the locals would like to do, rather than visiting pointless tourist attractions, boring museums and tedious ‘cultural events’.”
I can just plainly agree.

Image credit:

He goes on proposing a few “Other things to do” to escape corporate – and local – attempts to part your money from your pockets, and ultimately comments that supermarkets are often infinitely better than the “authentic” markets that, by definition, are created to lure in the tourist. And again, indulge in Mission  Empty Pocket.  I have been thinking for quite a while that what Tom Coote has written is unbelievably true. Especially in Asia.

Asians, of all the peoples in the world I met, seem to be the ones enjoying the globalizing world most than anyone else. Really.  And let’s face it: as much as many Asian countries would look so much better if people wore only traditional dresses, stop and think. Authentic is what REALLY is authentic; the true essence of life. And this essence, around Asia, is to be massively found within the malls’ walls. Flashing lights, Starbuck cafés, high heels, miniskirts and suits and ties. The oxen-pulled carts have been left out for good, although some Western traveler would have definitely loved to see them ply up and around the mall’s moving escalators. To cite the words of my Asian partner: “Why should we love regress, when we can finally have some progress? Should I dress up in rags to make you happy and give you the authentic experience?”. So, I argue that an authentic tour of China, Thailand and India would not be authentically complete if you did not pay at least a visit to these new temples of authenticity. Stroll up and down the aisles, check out some strange products, observe what locals try to fill their carts with. Look at the screaming babies and thumb through the books on offer. Get an insight into their real, modern culture. Join throngs of families looking for the new plasma television experience, or the latest improvement in whipping cream technology. And you would probably feel that those big differences you felt as you arrived are not as huge as you thought. It is a matter of perspectives. Like the one beautiful perspective I am having now, watching people walking inside of the mall from the safe air-condition comfort of a wirelessly powered Starbucks. This is my window of opportunity to the authentic world.

Posted by | Comments (3) 
Category: Asia, Vagabonding Life

3 Responses to “Authentic Asia: find it at the shopping mall”

  1. rubin pham Says:

    this is exactly the reason why i hate to see 7/11, mac donalds, and kentucky fried chicken when i travel to vietnam in early 2012.

  2. DEK Says:

    Why bother to go to another country if it “authentically” now looks like Minneapolis or Houston, albeit with some trifling language barrier? Minneapolis or Houston will cost less to visit, the water will be reliably safe to drink and you can understand everything that is being said. And the scams and frauds would more likely be ones you had already heard of. Most of us could even drive there, if we wanted to.

    I mean absolutely no criticism of the author, for tastes differ, but posts like this seem to me to be arguments against travel.

  3. Marco Ferrarese Says:

    Without taking any criticism but respecting opinions, I am not at all arguing against travel “to another country if it “authentically” now looks like Minneapolis or Houston”. I am just trying to bring attention to a real issue that I cannot ignore, as it keeps coming back daily in my travelling life. Possibly this happen because I know the locals good enough to really understand what is that they desire. Globalization has definitely taken its toll on the world, including the travel industry, and it would be in my opinion quite naive to visit one country and ignore what their inhabitants really want. It would maybe take a communal effort to visit such countries, and refer back to their inhabitants by explaining how such models of wealth may be wrong or inappropriate. But again, this is only my personal, humble opinion.

Leave a Reply













Vagabonding Audio Book at

Marco Polo Didnt Go There
Rolf's new book!



Roger: Without a doubt, travel should broaden your belief system. If it doesn’t,...

Rolf Potts: Good stuff, Barbara — thanks. Several of these apps were new to me.

Michelle Anderson: Great post and it’s a frequent question I’m asked as...

Pauline: Thank you so much for this. I am off on my first solo trip in May and this...

Pauline: Thank you so much for this. I am off on my first solo trip in Map and this...

Julia Wright: Barbara thank you for being the helpful person you are. The world needs...

Kathryn: Wow, I hope someone explained to the guy with the speaker that you can these...

Caroline: Thanks for the comment, Roger! Yes I agree, these kinds of incidents usually...

Andy: I know him personally, and he is NOT Rod Stewart, he’s actually a therapist...

Roger: Very good post Caroline. I can remember several automotive...






Lessons learned on the road vs. lessons learned in school
Must-have smart phone travel apps
People from cultures that prize individualism tend to misapprehend cultures that don’t
Mister Universe
Vagabonding Case Study: Nellie Huang
Especially the disasters are worth it
The secret of travel is to approximate the life of a local
A day spent wandering a city never gets old
Vagabonding Field Report: Exploring the vastness of Rome
How to educate a child while traveling

Subscribe to this blog's feed
Follow @rolfpotts